A new sort of thing I'll try to employ once a week. Hopefully it will stir your thoughts. This week's pressing question is: the Beach Boys or the Beatles, as posed by my pal, John Crodian.
This is what we had to say on the issue if you have the time to read it:
Nekrowax24: would you rather listen to the beatles or the beach boys?
MikeVeeeeee: right now?
MikeVeeeeee: or forever
Nekrowax24: forever
MikeVeeeeee: fuck
MikeVeeeeee: that's a hard question.
Nekrowax24: well what about right now?
MikeVeeeeee: the beach boys
MikeVeeeeee: but only because i havent heard nearly as much of the beach boys work
MikeVeeeeee: and right now they're very appealing to me
MikeVeeeeee: but forever... i dont know
MikeVeeeeee: probably the beatles
MikeVeeeeee: that's a tough one
MikeVeeeeee: you?
Nekrowax24: well the scenario isn't like if you could only listen to one for the rest of your life
Nekrowax24: because in that case I'd go for the Beatles
MikeVeeeeee: but that's what i think when you ask me that.
Nekrowax24: because there was more variation in their style
MikeVeeeeee: but right now you would be listening to the beach boys?
MikeVeeeeee: i dont know
MikeVeeeeee: well
Nekrowax24: yes beach boys definitely
MikeVeeeeee: would i be allowed to listen to brian wilson's solo stuff
Nekrowax24: but its a hard question for me
Nekrowax24: yes
MikeVeeeeee: as well as george harrison and john lennon's if i chose beatles
MikeVeeeeee: not ringo or paul's
MikeVeeeeee: i'll be alright without wings
Nekrowax24: haha
Nekrowax24: i don't know i like the beach boys but I can't get into it as much
Nekrowax24: there's some stuff of the beatles that I really can't stand though
MikeVeeeeee: yeah same here
Nekrowax24: like I never want to hear paperback writer ever ever again
MikeVeeeeee: YEAH
MikeVeeeeee: or Daytripper
MikeVeeeeee: FUCK that song
Nekrowax24: yes
Nekrowax24: now ticket to ride
Nekrowax24: actually
Nekrowax24: fuck ticket to ride too
Nekrowax24: but across the universe, rain, strawberry fields,
Nekrowax24: i guess i kind of hate the beatles
Nekrowax24: but rain is a great song
MikeVeeeeee: but i could listen to pet sounds or magical mystery tour over and over again.
MikeVeeeeee: oh and the white album?
Nekrowax24: word. but the beach boys' earlier stuff is so much more tolerable than the beatles'
MikeVeeeeee: smiley smile???
Nekrowax24: huh?
MikeVeeeeee: yeah, like surfin safari
MikeVeeeeee: the beach boys album smiley smile
MikeVeeeeee: good vibrationsssss
Nekrowax24: yeah word
MikeVeeeeee: yeah, i guess brian wilson sortof dropped off the planet for a while and made the beach boys suck
MikeVeeeeee: right when they could have been amazing
MikeVeeeeee: I'm going to pose this question to my music blog and see what kind of results show up.
Nekrowax24: do you prefer the beatles or the rolling stones?
Nekrowax24: for me it's the beatles hands down
Nekrowax24: i dont know why but i really fucking hate the rolling stones a lot
MikeVeeeeee: beatles
MikeVeeeeee: fuck the stones
Nekrowax24: i just think they're full of shit.
Reid's answer: "I like the Beatles... although... "Pet Sounds" is of course..."
Pleassseeee reply with your answer. Beatles or Beach Boys? Which would you prefer?
Thursday, January 15, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)


18 comments:
Uh, Beach Boys. Beatles suck dick.
And Stones over Beach Boys.
And you just lost all of your cred.
Clearly we differ here, Alex. Is it I who has lost the "cred", or you, sir?
rolling stones, barf
i need to listen to more than one album of the beach boys, so beatles for me as of now
but fuck, beatles forever? just the beatles? ughhh that would suck
beatles < beach boys
(beach boys had a better understanding of what made music good)
rolling stones > beatles and beach boys
(the beatles and beach boys dont have any balls to speak of. neither of them were brave enough to write sympathy for the devil. george harrison was too much of a pussy to play as manly guitar as keith richards. the rolling stones get a bad rap because they now kind of have this "dad rock" thing going on but people need to get over that ASAP. everything through 1971 trumps anything wilson or mccartney/lennon)
but... the kinks over all. really now, why arent we talking about the kinks. fuck you guys.
Beatles by far! I love the Beach Boys but the Beatles definitely have more of a following and influence on modern rock.
The Beach Boys are somewhere in there with Jimmy Buffet and the other surf rock island wannabees.
I like Dick Dale, though. I'm losing a lot of cred here so I'm gonna stop.
Hmm? I guess I never really thought about the Kinks, but then again, this was never really about the Stones either.
Also, let's not get all self-conscious on the comment section of my blog now! Just because Alex "Cred-Smasher" Launi thinks he's better than everyone for having "Sticky Fingers" on the ceiling above his bed, doesn't mean we all have to start holding our tongues. Dick Dale is rad, can't say the same for Buffet, but I still love the Beach Boys for all they stand for.
Surfin' USA in 2k9, boyz. Rollllll out!!
the rolling stones are rock n rolls bloated, vomit asphyxiated corpse.
when hannah and I were little, that was one of the ways we defined ourselves -- I was the beatles and she was the beach boys
also, anyone who says the stones are better than the beatles and the beach boys is clearly more interested in an appearance of "cool" than good music
um i dont know about that rivgah. i didnt grow up listening to the beatles. i grew up listening to the rolling stones. so the nostalgic ties most people have to the beatles (which i think is responsible for most of their popularity)... i dont have.
i think technically the beatles win. they really accomplished the most and certainly had the biggest influence on music.
i respect the beach boys, but i never go out of my way to listen to them. i never really understood all the hype over "pet sounds", either. but i still recognize the impact they had.
ok, now having said all that, the rolling stones are #1 in my book. if i had to listen to one band for the rest of my life, i'd probably go for the stones. have you ever listened to "sticky fingers"? genius, i tell you. i'll never forget the first time i heard "can't you hear me knocking"...i was sure that the rolling stones were going to take over the world.
how do you choose between the beach boys and the beatles?
or, perhaps the better question would be:
why would you choose between the beach boys and the beatles?
the point is, enjoy the beauty. just enjoy it. it doesn't matter if it's coming from john lennon's mouth/brain or bian wilson's. either way, the music is beatiful and it makes me happy when i'm sad.
oh, and only early stones.
purely hypothetical of course; and I agree, only early stones.
"also, anyone who says the stones are better than the beatles and the beach boys is clearly more interested in an appearance of "cool" than good music"
This could not be more wrong! You've clearly only been exposed to the mainstream, wmgk rolling stones and none of their earlier work. You poor poor sheltered child..
when you guys are ready to get serious, let me know and we can listen to some Grand Funk Railroad. Fuck cred.
Pet Sounds > Beatles
Beach Boys < later Beatles stuff
the Kinks > Beatles and Beach Boys
oh and
Kinks>Zombies>Beatles and Beach Boys
ahaha
Oh and how can you not understand the hype over Pet Sounds? That shit is beautiful and musically has alot more different things going on. Just turn it on and listen, and youll see.
Post a Comment